Kate Crehan An introduction to the concept of culture in Gramsci’s writing of culture and the links between culture and power in relation to anthropology. BOOK REVIEWS Gramsci, Culture, and Anthropology. By Kate Crehan. Berkeley: Uni sity of California Press, Pp. x, $ cloth, $ paper. Download Citation on ResearchGate | On Dec 1, , Les Field and others published Gramsci, Culture, and Anthropology Kate Crehan }.
|Published (Last):||11 July 2008|
|PDF File Size:||10.40 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||14.82 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Gramsci on Culture 4. Some Assumptions Part II: If class analysis is to be defended well, it needs to be defended not just in crean where it appears to have patent explanatory power-its ability to explain U.
Putting “culture” into context
We can learn from others only if we take them seriously enough to imagine situations in which they might in fact be wrong about some things, in ways that we can specify and understand. Entre santos, cumbias y piquetes: Class consciousness thus amounts to being thought by cultuure class—as if the constative element of class consciousness reduces to the performative element, the abstract act of thinking itself.
Crehan asserts that the anthropological concept is mistaken, and mystifies the internal and external heterogeneity of these indigenous communities, heterogeneities marked by conflict and contradiction. If post-Marxists like Laclau and Mouffe deconstruct class interest by deconstructing base and superstructure, Crehan critiques base and superstructure, as noted above, in defense of class interest.
Finally, it ought to be noted how easily cultural relativism can be manipulated by imperialism. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed. Crehan describes how this notion of autonomy became fused with the idea of culture as a bounded whole. And, not to end on a diminutive note, but it is short, under pages, and eminently accessible to undergraduates.
Obviously, this is not the place for a defense of moral realism but let me make a few assertions by way of conclusion: The problems with his concept of class consciousness have not gone unnoticed, detailed criticisms in the Marxist camp coming from Louis Althusser and Terry Eagleton among others. Gramsci Now Bibliography Index.
Home About Editorial Board. Kate Crehan makes extensive use of Gramsci’s own writings, including his preprison journalism and prison letters as well gransci the prison notebooks.
Gramsci, Culture and Anthropology by Kate Crehan – Paperback – University of California Press
Gramsci did not want merely to study the world, but change it. As critics have noted, such a view, while claiming to unite theory and cultue seriously impoverishes the former. Gramsci, culture and anthropology Kate A. She shows how the concept reduces the heterogeneity of gender practices in the working class as well as the heterogeneity and contradictory character of class crrehan. Account Options Sign in. Intellectuals and the Production of Culture.
Crehan examines the challenge that Gramsci’s approach poses to common anthropological assumptions about the nature of “culture” as well as the potential usefulness of Gramsci’s writings for contemporary anthropologists.
Gramsci Now Bibliography Index. Gramsci, Culture and Anthropology also provides an account of the intellectual and political contexts within which he was writing. These debates are having a wider impact on the discipline. The AAA has now voted in favour of a change in its ethics code that specifically draws a line between legitimate anthropological research and spying for the antnropology. The annual meeting of the American Anthropological Association AAAattended by over 6, people from all over the world, featured several packed meetings about the occupation of Iraq and the ethics of anthropological engagement with the US military.
Crehan argues with conviction that there is much in Gramsci that should be of value to anthropologists. University of California Pr Amazon. Moral realism reconciles fact and value, the normative and the empirical, and cogently reconciles interest relativity here, class interest and objectivity, including moral objectivity. Crehan antbropology the challenge that Gramsci’s approach poses to common anthropological assumptions about the nature bramsci “culture” as well as the potential usefulness of Gramsci’s writings for contemporary anthropologists.
In the last twenty years Antonio Gramsci has become a major presence in British and American anthropology, especially for anthropologists working on issues of culture and power. Realism facilitates this deeper process of mutual recognition and understanding. This is however a problematic formulation as Marxist and post Marxist critics have noted, the latter delighting in the view that the last instance never comes.
This refusal to discuss or theorize any future culture parallels the refusal to specify the content of class consciousness Viewed from another angle, the normative role theory would play to guide or shape the relation of present to future disappears. The book also provides an account of the intellectual and political contexts within which he was writing.
Metropolitan Books,p. I would make one small criticism of her generally valuable discussion of base and superstructure. The Problem of Historicism I have spent some significant time on this relatively modest book because I think it contributes to the very important project of strengthening class analysis.
Culture and History 5. In the last twenty years Antonio Gramsci has become a major presence in British and American anthropology, especially for anthropologists working on issues of culture and power. She is the author of a number of works including Gramsci, Culture and Anthropology Pluto, Given the lack cultture understanding or knowledge creahn the other, however, the ascription of xrehan and of equality among cultures is either meaningless or patronizing.
In the last year he published his first book, Collectivities: She traces most citations of Gramsci in anthropology to the interpretations by cultural historian Raymond Williams and the anthropologists John and Jean Cultuee. Crehan nevertheless criticizes this work for its— now canonical— emphasis o n race class and gender as co-primary intersecting elements of identity:. Inequality and Its Narratives. Fortunately, the concept of class interest that undergirds class analysis is fully defensible.
Kate Crehan makes extensive His work has become one of the most cited sources on power and hegemony. Gramsci’s Life and Work 3. This book explores Gramsci’s understanding of culture and the links between culture and power in relation to anthropology. Insofar as class consciousness on this view is equivalent to tuning in to the essential tendencies of the present, class consciousness is deprived of an intelligible future.